Home » Attacked by a Colleague

Attacked by a Colleague

Facts

Mr Weddall was a Deputy Manager of a care home in Norwich. Mr Marsh was a Health Assistant at the care home, and he had a previous conviction for assault. The two men did not get on. One evening in 2006 Mr Weddall was on duty when one of the nightshift employees called in sick. Mr Weddall called Mr Marsh at home to see if he wanted another shift. Unbeknown to Mr Weddall, Mr Marsh had had a bad day and by 6pm was drunk. Mr Marsh thought that Mr Weddall was mocking him.

After the call, Mr Marsh rang back, saying that he intended to resign. He then rode to the care home on his bicycle, and when he saw Mr Weddall, attacked him. The first judge found that it was “an utterly unprovoked attack, very violent, and that no words of any significance were spoken . . . before the blows were struck.” The Health Assistant was pulled off the Deputy Manager by another employee. Mr Marsh apologised and then fled. In the Crown Court he pleaded guilty to the attack and was sentenced to 15 months imprisonment. Mr Weddall sued the company for his injuries.

Was the the care home ordered to pay compensation?

No. Lord Justice Pill concluded that the violence was the employee’s response to a routine request and that the attack was an independent venture, separate and distinct from the employment as a Health Assistant at a care home i.e. the assault did not happen in the course of the employment. So, the judge concluded that the assault was not the responsibility of the employer, and so Mr Weddall didn’t receive any compensation from his employer.

Truth Legal’s Comments

We think this was an unfair result because the assault occurred at work and as a result of a work situation. Although this is an unhelpful case for people assaulted by their colleagues at work, other decided cases suggest that suing an employer for violence carried out by a colleague is possible.

See the full case here.

social

Share Case Study

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on email
Email
Share on print
Print

get in touch

We’re not like
other law firms

Ethically driven

Truth Legal was founded on the idea of putting ethics at the centre of legal services. 

Ethical working is at our core: in treating people fairly, being open and honest, and taking social responsibility. We sponsor a large section of woodland near Harrogate, planting a tree for every one of the clients we represent.

Real lawyers, real people

We believe a good lawyer shouldn’t just offer technical expertise, but a real understanding of what you’re going through and how best to help you. 

Above all, our team are dedicated to their clients – whether that is guiding them through legal complexities, securing compensation, or simply fighting for what’s right.

We won’t blind you with jargon – we give advice clearly. And when technical terms can’t be avoided we explain them in full.

Exceptional service

In contrast to some firms, we don’t overload our lawyers with cases. Our team provide clients with a more personal service, meaning we can dedicate the proper time to your matter.

Just read our client reviews to see what a difference this can make.

Fill out our quick online form with your details and we’ll come back to you

Consent(Required)

© 2022 Truth Legal Ltd is registered in England & Wales (08031477), VAT Registered (135 2552 31),
Authorised and Regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (568741).

Website by browndog.agency