Home » Medical experts in a personal injury claim

Medical experts in a personal injury claim

By some distance the medical expert in a personal injury claim fulfils the most crucial function of all. It is the medical expert who determines what injury the Claimant has sustained as a result of an accident and, crucially, what the future holds for the Claimant (the prognosis). It is the future loss which usually adds the large sums to a compensation claim.

Although the medical expert is instructed and paid for by the Claimant or Defendant Solicitors, the medical expert usually has a duty to the court to provide their report independent of who is paying them. Claimants often fail to explain their symptoms to a medical expert – see our blog.

Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules governs what any expert in a civil claim should do. Often a party – either a Claimant Solicitor or Defendant Solicitor – can ask a medical expert questions about the claimant’s injuries. This is known as a Part 35 Question.

Normally, before the issuing of proceedings and the service of proceedings, irrespective of the value of the personal injury claim, the Claimant uses the medical experts as recommended and appointed by the Claimant’s Solicitors. In higher value claims, after the service of proceedings, as requested in a directions questionnaire the defendant Solicitors will usually be allowed to instruct their own medical experts (though still with the purpose of assisting the court) to examine the injured Claimant. In such high value claims, the medical experts sometimes have to meet and prepare joint medical reports on their areas of agreement and disagreement. If a high value claim goes to trial, then the medical experts usually have to attend the trial in order to give oral evidence to the court in order to assist the court to value the compensation element.

In complex claims, often numerous types of medical experts are needed to provide medical reports on the injuries. For example, if a Claimant suffers a serious whiplash-type injury in a Road Traffic Accident then the Claimant Solicitors may obtain a report from a GP expert or an Accident and Emergency expert in the first instance. In serious injury claims those experts may recommend to the court that the injured Claimant is examined by, say, a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon. The Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon might, in due course, say, recommend that the whiplash symptoms are examined by a Consultant Neurologist. And if the Consultant Neurologist is of the opinion that the injuries requires an opinion from a Consultant in Pain Medicine, then a Claimant is advised to obtain such a report.

The value of Claim, not just the pain, suffering and loss of amenity element but also the financial losses and care and assistance claim, is entirely dependent on the medical expert opinions.

Truth Legal have been hired to train medical experts on what to do at such in medical examinations.

In higher value claims a Claimant or defendant solicitor is likely to want to have a meeting with the medical expert in order to test the strength of the expert’s opinion. Sometimes a solicitor will be instructed by their client to find a medical expert who is likely to provide a favourable report. This is known as “expert shopping” and it is frowned upon by courts.

Often medical experts highlight medical issues which the Claimant was previously unaware. For a Claimant, therefore, the opportunity to have a top medical expert examine them together with their full medical records is a very useful experience which can help the Claimant to obtain the right treatment.

Speak to us about your case
Harrogate 01423 788 538
Leeds 0113 483 1200

Simply fill out a few details, a summary of your case and we’ll get in touch with you within 4 hours.

social

Share Post

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on email
Email
Share on print
Print

get in touch

We’re not like
other law firms

Ethically driven

Truth Legal was founded on the idea of putting ethics at the centre of legal services. 

Ethical working is at our core: in treating people fairly, being open and honest, and taking social responsibility. We sponsor a large section of woodland near Harrogate, planting a tree for every one of the clients we represent.

Real lawyers, real people

We believe a good lawyer shouldn’t just offer technical expertise, but a real understanding of what you’re going through and how best to help you. 

Above all, our team are dedicated to their clients – whether that is guiding them through legal complexities, securing compensation, or simply fighting for what’s right.

We won’t blind you with jargon – we give advice clearly. And when technical terms can’t be avoided we explain them in full.

Exceptional service

In contrast to some firms, we don’t overload our lawyers with cases. Our team provide clients with a more personal service, meaning we can dedicate the proper time to your matter.

Just read our client reviews to see what a difference this can make.

Fill out our online form and we’ll come back to you:

Consent(Required)

Or call us today:

Harrogate 01423 788 538
Leeds 0113 483 1200

© 2022 Truth Legal Ltd is registered in England & Wales (08031477), VAT Registered (135 2552 31),
Authorised and Regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (568741).

Website by browndog.agency